Yawning May Promote Social Bonding Even Between Dogs And Humans

May 15, 2017
Originally published on May 15, 2017 7:29 am

Bears do it; bats do it. So do guinea pigs, dogs and humans. They all yawn. It's a common animal behavior, but one that is something of a mystery.

There's still no consensus on the purpose of a yawn, says Robert Provine, professor of psychology and neuroscience at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County. Provine has studied what he calls "yawn science" since the early 1980s, and he's published dozens of research articles on it. He says the simple yawn is not so simple.

"Yawning may have the dubious distinction of being the least understood common human behavior," Provine says.

There are many causes for yawning. Boredom, sleepiness, hunger, anxiety and stress — all cause changes in brain chemistry, which can trigger a spontaneous yawn. But it's not clear what the yawn accomplishes. One possibility is the yawn perks you up by increasing heart rate, blood pressure and respiratory function.

"[Yawning] stirs up our physiology and it plays an important role in shifting from one state to another," Provine says.

When violinists get ready to go on stage to play a concerto, they often yawn, says Provine. So do Olympians right before a competition, or paratroopers getting ready to do their first jump. One study found that yawning has a similar impact on the brain as a dose of caffeine.

But not all yawn researchers agree with this theory.

"No specific arousing effect of yawning on the brain could be observed in at least five studies," says Adrian Guggisberg, a professor in the department of clinical neurosciences at the University of Geneva.

Guggisberg and fellow researchers reviewed several theories of yawning and concluded that the arousal theory lacks evidence. What they did find were several studies that show yawning is highly contagious among humans, suggesting that "yawns might have a social and communicative function," Guggisberg said in an e-mail.

Looking at yawns, hearing yawns, thinking about yawns or talking about yawns will likely trigger a contagious response. Contagious yawning may have evolved in early humans to boost social bonding, according to Provine. A good group yawn could serve to perk everyone up to be more vigilant about danger, he says.

Another piece of evidence backing up the social bonding theory of yawning is a 2011 study by Ivan Norsicia and Elisabetta Palagi that found people are more likely to copy a yawn if they know the person who is yawning. A stranger's yawn is less likely to trigger a contagious response. And while babies yawn spontaneously, children don't engage in contagious yawning until about age 4 — around the same time they're becoming more socially connected.

Now, what about other animals? We know that all vertebrates, critters with backbones, yawn spontaneously. But very few yawn contagiously.

"Until the last few years, the feeling was that contagious yawning was unique to humans," Provine says.

But recently, two more species have been added to the list of contagious yawners: dogs and chimpanzees. When two groups of chimpanzees were shown videos of familiar and unfamiliar chimps yawning, the group watching the chimps they knew engaged in more contagious yawning. This study, by Matthew Campbell and Frans de Waal, supports the theory that yawning plays a role in the evolution of social bonding and empathy.

And dogs not only catch each others' yawns, they are susceptible to human yawning as well. In one study, 29 dogs watched a human yawning and 21 of them yawned as well — suggesting that interspecies yawning could help in dog-human communication.


Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

So obviously, teens aren't the only ones yawning. It's something everyone does - humans but also bears, bats, guinea pigs, giraffes. Yawning is common animal behavior. Here's reporter Michelle Trudeau. And no matter how interesting Michelle's story is, I dare you not to yawn during this story.

MICHELLE TRUDEAU, BYLINE: Let me introduce the father of yawn research.

ROBERT PROVINE: I'm Robert Provine, professor of psychology and neuroscience at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.

TRUDEAU: Provine has studied what he calls yawn science since the early 1980s, publishing dozens of research articles on it. Turns out, the simple yawn - not so simple.

PROVINE: There are many causes for yawning, such as boredom, sleepiness.

TRUDEAU: Hunger, anxiety, stress - they all cause changes in brain chemistry which triggers a yawn. But, says Provine, there's still no consensus on the purpose of a yawn. One strong contender is that a yawn perks you up by increasing heart rate, blood pressure and respiratory function. It's a behavior...

PROVINE: It stirs up our physiology, and it plays an important role in shifting from one state to another. For example, with violinists getting ready to go onto a stage play to play a concerto...

TRUDEAU: They often yawn, as do some Olympians right after competition.

PROVINE: Paratroopers getting ready to do their first jump - they are also yawning.

TRUDEAU: But to Provine, the most intriguing aspect of yawning is that it's highly contagious.

PROVINE: In fact, yawning is so contagious that anything having to do with it will trigger a contagious response - looking at yawns, hearing yawns, thinking about yawns or talking about yawns, as we're doing right now.

TRUDEAU: Contagious yawning may have evolved in early humans to boost social bonding, says Provine. A good group yawn perks everyone up to be more vigilant about danger.

PROVINE: When one person yawns and others yawn, this involves a neurologically programmed bonding of individuals.

TRUDEAU: The social bonding theory has some evidence. For example, you're more likely to yawn if the yawner is someone from your family versus a stranger. And newborns - they yawn spontaneously, but they don't start to show contagious yawning until age 4 or so, around the same time they're becoming more socially connected. And one more finding - individuals with autism, a disorder that has impaired social bonding - they have relatively little contagious yawning.

Now what about other animals? We know that all vertebrates - that's critters with backbones - they all yawn spontaneously, but very few yawn contagiously.

PROVINE: Till the last few years now, the feeling was that contagious yawning was unique to humans.

TRUDEAU: But recently, two more species have been added to the list of contagious yawners.

PROVINE: Our cousins the chimpanzees as well as highly social mammals, such as dogs.

TRUDEAU: Provine suggests you do a little at-home experiment. Watch your dog when he yawns. Do you catch the yawn yourself? If so, that's a brilliant demonstration of contagious yawning between different species. For NPR News, I'm Michelle Trudeau.

(SOUNDBITE OF IMAGINED HERBAL FLOWS' "CLOUDS") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.